Recently, nearly every time I’m asked to appear as a “talking head” on a talk show, the subject of torture comes up, and I find myself trying to clarify that what we call “torture” would be laughed about in many parts of the world.
That being said, and since most talk shows give you mere seconds to make your point, let me clarify a few things:
I think torture is horrible. The evil that mankind has inflicted on each other since creation is beyond my comprehension. When I visit museums, or read books about ancient (or not so ancient) history, and see the devices men have created to torment other human beings it truly sickens me. I honestly can’t imagine how the human mind could invent such horrible contraptions as the “breast ripper”, the “brazen bull”, or “the rack”.
However, they exist, and the fact that we in America do not use them speaks volumes about us as a nation. As shocking as it may seem, in may parts of the world, disfiguring torture or some type of beating is to be expected if you’re picked up by the police. Mr. Miranda? Sorry, they’ve never heard of him. Innocent until proven guilty? The concept doesn’t exist.
Which brings me to the issue of waterboarding. I don’t claim to be an expert on the practice, and I’ve certainly never been waterboarded, but many of our military members have, and several prominent journalists have been also. It’s no doubt a miserable experience, but is it torture, in the true sense of the word? Is listening to music you can’t stand, played loudly, torture? Sleep deprivation?
All of those things sound like misery to me, and I have personal friends who have been captives, and who truly know what it means to be beaten and tortured, so when we’re talking about being frightened by a dog, or having panties put on your head, we may be talking humiliation, but don’t insult my friends’ sacrifice by calling humiliation torture.
When I think of torture, I think of beatings, being burned, raped, mutilated, having various parts of your body cut off while you’re still alive, beheading - you know, the things they do to our soldiers when they get ahold of them. Guess they’re not interested in following our examples, are they?
I hear a lot of talk about America “setting the example” in the way we treat prisoners. Why do you suppose that Somali pirate was grinning so broadly when he arrived in the States? Because he knew he was going to be tortured? To the contrary - he knows that we won’t do anything to him, and he’s never eaten so well in his life.
I wish “enhanced interrogation techniques” weren’t necessary, and in a perfect world, they wouldn’t be. Everyone would play nice, and no one would take your stuff. This may be news to the left, but we’re not there yet, so we must do all we can to protect our citizens from the bad guys, who don’t give us information just because it’s the right thing to do. Anyone who could plot to kill innocents is devoid of a conscience, get it?
Are we perfect? Of course not. Have there been abuses of power? Most certainly. But to accuse us of large scale torture is unfair, and merely emboldens our enemies. Let’s not forget that the so-called leaders of many of the detainees couldn’t care less if they’re ever returned alive. They’re not longer useful.
We must have a code of conduct that we adhere to, not because our enemies will agree to it, but because we never want to reduce ourselves to their level. But in the meantime, until someone can show me proof that the U.S. truly “tortures” people, like they do in the detainees’ native countries, I won’t lump uncomfortable treatment into the “torture” category. And to put torture into perspective, this is what they do in the Middle East… http://www.thoughtsongod.com/?p=4125